Best Auto Repair Shops
in New York City

102 ST LEXINGTON AVE

NEW YORK, NY 10029

123 AUTO SERVICE INC

BROOKLYN, NY 11234

Customers consistently praise 123 AUTO SERVICE INC for accurate, effective diagnostics and clear explanations of problems; timely, quick turnaround on repairs; honest, transparent recommendations and billing; reasonable, fair pricing; and service that builds long-term trust and repeat business.

1274 WESTCHESTER

BRONX, NY 10459

1280 ALLERTON AVE

BRONX, NY 10469

138TH STREET INC

BRONX, NY 10451

1447 POWER MUFFLER

BRONX, NY 10452

145TH STREET AUTO

NEW YORK, NY 10039

155TH STREET AUTO

NEW YORK, NY 10032

170TH STREET AUTO

BRONX, NY 10452

1811 AUTO REPAIR

BROOKLYN, NY 11231

Mixed customer sentiment. Positive themes: - Owner described as personable/friendly. - Staff frequently called knowledgeable and honest. - Friendly atmosphere and generally reasonable/priced services. - Prompt inspection/diagnostic service noted by several reviewers. Negative themes: - Timeliness/reliability concerns: reports of missed deadlines and delays. - Quality-control issues: some customers said vehicles were returned in worse condition or with new damage. - Communication gaps around delays/repair status cited in some reviews. Net impression: Many customers praise the staff and value, but a meaningful subset report reliability and vehicle-condition problems that undermine trust. Customers are advised to confirm timelines, get repair/inspection details in writing, and inspect the vehicle at pickup.

1820 EXCELLENT AUTO

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10306

- Limited customer reviews found for 1820 Excellent Auto (1820 Richmond Rd, Staten Island, NY); none clearly describe repair services. - Available customer feedback pertains mainly to car wash services and includes a positive mention of an employee named Romero. - Two MapQuest customer reviews located for the Exxon service station at the same address: one praises staff professionalism and attentiveness; the other reports a failed inspection over a small windshield-wiper tear. These MapQuest reviews likely refer to the Exxon station and may not reflect 1820 Excellent Auto’s services or reputation. - Summary conclusion: no substantive customer reviews specifically about auto repair work at 1820 Excellent Auto were found; only car-wash praise (Romero) and nearby Exxon reviews of uncertain attribution.

1ST AVE CAR WASH & LUBE

NEW YORK, NY 10029

Overall: Customers give a mixed picture — reliable for fast, friendly basic services but inconsistent on detail and billing; some reports of vehicle damage. What customers praise - Fast, friendly service for quick stops. - Good option for routine oil changes and exterior/hand washes/hand-dry. Recurring negatives reported by customers - Interior vacuuming often rushed or incomplete; missed spots are common. - Inconsistent attention to detail across visits and staff (cleaning quality varies). - Upselling and billing issues: unexpected charges or pressure to add services. - A minority of customers report vehicle damage (scratches/dents) or issues after service. Practical notes for customers - Best choice for quick exterior washes and basic maintenance; avoid if you need meticulous interior detailing. - Inspect vehicle and service receipt before leaving and ask for itemized charges to reduce disputes. Specializes in Maintenance, Starting and Charging.

2 BROTHERS AUTO INC

BROOKLYN, NY 11220

Overwhelmingly positive customer sentiment: reviewers consistently praise the shop for honesty and reliability, knowledgeable and friendly technicians, clear communication and fair, transparent estimates/pricing. Customers report efficient, timely repairs and prompt turnaround, with affordable bodywork and fair overall costs. Strong customer care is repeatedly noted—helpful staff, good follow-up, and vehicles returned clean after service. No consistent negative patterns appear in the available summaries. Specializes in Cooling, Diagnostic, Maintenance.

2 IN 1 TIRE & AUTO

BROOKLYN, NY 11230

Mixed customer sentiment: experiences range from very positive to strongly negative, indicating inconsistent service quality. Positive themes - Multiple customers (named reviewers include Bruce, Jonathan, Albert) describe staff as professional, courteous, honest, and helpful. - Some customers report reliable repairs and express satisfaction with outcomes. Negative themes - Several complaints allege overcharging, upselling, and pressure to accept additional services; surprises on final invoices are reported. - Specific customer-reported charges cited in reviews include roughly $3,000 and $984. - Some customers report recurring issues after service, suggesting repairs were ineffective or incomplete. Notable/summary assessment - The shop appears to deliver good service for some customers but has enough serious negative reports (cost disputes, repeat problems) to make outcomes unpredictable. - When using this shop, customers should obtain written, itemized estimates, confirm needed repairs, and consider a second opinion for major work. Specializes in Tires. ACDelco auto parts supplier

2000 AUTO SERVICE

NEW YORK, NY 10027

2020 AUTO SERVICE

NEW YORK, NY 10027

21ST CENTURY

BRONX, NY 10461

24 HR CAR REPAIR

BRONX, NY 10460

26 MOTORS SERVICE

BRONX, NY 10466

3010 GAS CORP

BROOKLYN, NY 11235

Overall sentiment: Positive Strengths (frequent customer comments) - Technicians, particularly Steve and his crew, are frequently praised for being knowledgeable, skilled, and honest. - Service is described as friendly, helpful, and catering to individual customer needs. - Customers appreciate the honest assessments and fair pricing. - The location is convenient and the employees are helpful for both gas and mechanical services. Weaknesses (if any) - Some customers find the credit/cash pricing difference for gasoline to be an annoyance.

312 AUTO SHOP CORP

BROOKLYN, NY 11218

Overall positive customer sentiment: reviewers emphasize affordability, high-quality service/workmanship, and efficient — timely — repairs. Customers portray the shop as a good option for drivers seeking cost-effective, reliable, and quick auto repairs.

348 EAST INC

NEW YORK, NY 10029

3514 COMPLETE AUTO

BROOKLYN, NY 11218

Overall sentiment: mixed (previously described as generally positive). What customers praise: - Quality bodywork and accurate paint matching. - Quick, professional service when work is completed satisfactorily. - Helpful, customer-oriented staff — several reviews specifically name Vanya, Leo, and Don Julio and praise their service. - Competitive/reasonable pricing cited in multiple positive reviews. What customers complain about: - Reports of overcharging or unexpected charges. - Instances of poor-quality workmanship and unresolved repairs. - A few reviews describe confrontational or unprofessional behavior from the owner when disputes arise. Change from previous summary: - The earlier summary emphasized generally positive feedback; the latest research adds a notable set of negative experiences (overcharging, unresolved repairs, confrontational owner behavior), shifting the overall picture to mixed. The previously noted positives and staff names remain consistent.

36TH ST AUTO REPAIR

BROOKLYN, NY 11218

36TH ST AUTO REPAIR — customer review summary - Overall impression: mixed but generally positive; many customers praise honesty and value, while a notable minority report reliability and transparency problems. - Positives reported: - Friendly, family-like staff and technicians described as honest and trustworthy. - Fair pricing reported by several customers. - Good paint/bodywork and competent handling of insurance claims (reviews referencing “36th St Collision” indicate solid paint and claims support). - Several repeat/loyal customers who had satisfactory repairs and service. - Negatives reported: - Frequent complaints about long delays and slow turnaround times. - Recurring or unresolved issues after service; some customers had to return for follow-ups. - Occasional poor communication and unprofessional behavior reported by some patrons. - Surprise or added charges in some cases. - A minority of reviews criticize repair quality or workmanship on specific jobs. - Context from nearby shops (for comparison): - J & S Auto Repair: generally praised for honesty, quality bodywork, and fair pricing. - M USA Auto Repair: mixed — loyal satisfied customers but at least one complaint about delays and unprofessionalism. - Practical takeaways (from recurring review themes): - Experiences are inconsistent — many customers are happy, but a significant minority report problems. - Recommended precautions: get a written estimate, confirm expected turnaround time, ask about warranties/guarantees, document work, and consider a second opinion for major repairs. Specializes in Maintenance.