Service Buddy

Auto Repair Shops in Shirley, New York

Find trusted, verified mechanics in Shirley. Compare labor rates, specialties, and certifications from 17 local repair shops.

Local Chain Savings

Current Deals at Chains in Shirley

Jiffy LubeCoupon
$25 Off Signature Synthetic Oil Change

Showing 17 of 17 shops

S

Shirley, NY

17 shops
Street view of AE Auto Service
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

AE Auto Service

📍664 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967

Street view of AE AUTO SERVICE INC
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

AE AUTO SERVICE INC

📍664 MONTAUK HWY, SHIRLEY, NY 11967

Street view of Azion Auto Service
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

Azion Auto Service

📍610 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967

Street view of Discount Tire - Shirley, NY
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

Discount Tire - Shirley, NY

📍986 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967

Discount Tire - Shirley, NY in Shirley, NY

Street view of J & C Tire Sales Inc
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

J & C Tire Sales Inc

📍664 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967

Street view of J&C Tire Sales
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

J&C Tire Sales

📍879 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967

Street view of J&R AUTO BODY& REPAR
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

J&R AUTO BODY& REPAR

📍52 MCGRAW ST, SHIRLEY, NY 11967

Street view of Jiffy Lube - Shirley, NY
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

Jiffy Lube - Shirley, NY

📍882 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967

Jiffy Lube - Shirley, NY in Shirley, NY

Street view of Jiffy Lube Oil Change
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

Jiffy Lube Oil Change

📍882 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967

Street view of MAVIS DISCOUNT TIRE
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

MAVIS DISCOUNT TIRE

📍986 MONTAUK HWY, SHIRLEY, NY 11967

Street view of MZM AUTO CARE INC
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

MZM AUTO CARE INC

📍741 MONTAUK HIGHWAY, SHIRLEY, NY 11967

Street view of MZM REPAIR INC
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

MZM REPAIR INC

📍741 MONTAUK HWY, SHIRLEY, NY 11967

Street view of SHORELINE AUTO
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

SHORELINE AUTO

📍610 MONTAUK HWY, SHIRLEY, NY 11967

Street view of SOUTH SHORE
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

SOUTH SHORE

📍19 THE GREEN, SHIRLEY, NY 11967

Mixed reviews: honest, professional workmanship praised, but watch for unexpected extra charges and salvage-related issues.

🛡️ None
Street view of STS TIRE
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

STS TIRE

📍532 WILLIAM FLYD PKY, SHIRLEY, NY 11967

Street view of TIRE CITY INC
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

TIRE CITY INC

📍1015 MONTAUK HWY, SHIRLEY, NY 11967

Street view of WOODS SMITH POINT
📍 Street View
Verified Mechanic

WOODS SMITH POINT

📍18 HAVENWOOD DRIVE, SHIRLEY, NY 11967

Common Repairs & Costs in Shirley

Understand typical pricing for popular auto services in the Shirley area before you visit a mechanic.

View all repair cost guides →

Auto Repair in Shirley — Common Questions

How do I find a good mechanic in Shirley?+

Start by browsing our directory of verified Shirley auto repair shops above. Look for shops with strong reviews, relevant specialties for your vehicle, and transparent pricing. You can also upload your mechanic's quote to our free AI tool to check if you're being charged fairly.

How much does auto repair cost in Shirley?+

Repair costs in Shirley, New York vary based on the service type, vehicle make, and shop. Common services like oil changes typically run $30–$80, while brake pads range from $150–$400 per axle. For an accurate comparison, upload your quote and our AI will compare prices against local benchmarks.

What should I look for in a Shirley auto repair shop?+

Look for ASE-certified mechanics, transparent written estimates, positive reviews, and shops that specialize in your vehicle type. Our directory shows each shop's specialties and recommendations. Check our Repair FAQs to learn typical costs and what questions to ask your mechanic.

Already have a repair quote?

Upload your mechanic's bill and our AI will tell you if the prices are fair.

Check Your Quote →