Chevrolet Cruz 2017 Repair Quote Check | Indianapolis, Indiana Prices

1. Two New Tires – $932

What it should cost:

• Parts (2 mid-range tires): $300–$700
• Labor (install, balance, possible alignment): $135–$363
• Reasonable Range: Typically $435–$1,063 (with pricey tires), but $932 leans very high unless these are specialty or premium performance tires.

What we see:

• Unless these tires are a high-end brand (like Michelin Pilot Sport or similar), $932 for two is at the top end for any normal sedan tire. For a 2017 Chevy Cruze, standard all-season tires usually run $100–$180 each retail, so $932 would be high even with balancing and alignment.
• Labor for just two tires is about $135–$218 (plus more if they’re charging for alignment). There might be some room if you requested premium tires or if there’s an add-on like road hazard coverage—otherwise, this feels steep.

Upsell risk:

• Common tire upsells include: nitrogen fills, road hazard warranties, unnecessary alignments, or tire “certificates.”
• Double check what’s included—if it’s basic all-seasons and standard install, shop around. If you do want performance tires, ask for itemized quotes.

Advice:

• Unless top-tier performance tires or specialty items are needed, get a detailed breakdown, and consider quoting a couple other shops for two decent quality tires (with install and balance). Ask if an alignment is included and if it’s truly needed.

2. Wheel Bearing Replacement – $932

What it should cost:

• Parts & Labor: $250–$450 for most Chevys, including Cruze.
• High side for premium hubs/parts: Maybe $500–$600, but $932 is excessive unless there’s a rare or premium part involved.

What we see:

• This is extremely high for the Cruze. Even at “dealer” pricing, $932 for one bearing is rare—especially since independent shops were quoted as low as $23–$26/hr labor and typical parts are not unusually expensive for this car.
• Often, shops “upsell” by claiming related components must be changed, or add excessive labor charges.

Upsell risk:

• Watch for claims of “hub assembly replacement required” or convincing to do both sides “just in case.”
• Make sure the quote is only for the failed side, and that the part itself isn’t marked up way above retail.

Advice:

• This price is too high for a single bearing replacement. Ask for a written breakdown. Check again with a reputable independent mechanic—there might be a $400–$600 saving.

3. Oil Change – $932

What it should cost:

• Labor: $68–$145
• Full synthetic oil and filter: $60–$120 at most Midwest shops, even for a Cruze.

What we see:

• This is wildly overpriced—possibly a clerical error, but it’s 8–10 times what should be paid.
• Even dealers rarely charge more than $100–$150 on full synthetic changes.

Upsell risk:

• Oil change is a very common loss-leader, so extra “flushes” or “system treatments” are common upsells. If quoted $932 just for an oil change, it’s a major red flag.
• A half-price oil change offer was found at Automotive Service Group (ASG) in Indy—a more normal price can be expected at most local chains.

Advice:

• Do NOT pay $932 for a basic oil change on this car. This isn’t normal—get a second opinion or another shop quote. If this price wasn’t a typo, find another shop, fast.

General Thoughts

• Total quoted: $2,796 for three basic services. This is way too high for a Cruze worth $7,000–$15,500, especially given the simplicity of the jobs.
• It’s not uncommon for certain shops to inflate prices—possibly hoping the customer doesn’t realize the normal range. It is reasonable to say, “I’ll shop around,” or ask for a line-item breakdown.
• None of these jobs (except possibly tires, if opting for a specific high-end brand) should cost more than about half the prices listed above—even dealer service centers charge less.

Recommended Actions

• Call or check online with at least one other local independent mechanic for similar quotes (especially for the bearing and oil change).
• Ask the current shop for itemized pricing. If they won’t provide it, consider walking away.
• Take advantage of oil change promotions locally—such as ASG Automotive’s half-off special.
• Unless high-end tires were specifically requested, question the tire price and check what’s being quoted.