Best Auto Repair Shops
in Staten Island
Compare 176 verified mechanics in and around Staten Island, New York. See reviews, fair prices, and specialties.
Showing 24 of 176 shops
1820 EXCELLENT AUTO
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10306
- Limited customer reviews found for 1820 Excellent Auto (1820 Richmond Rd, Staten Island, NY); none clearly describe repair services. - Available customer feedback pertains mainly to car wash services and includes a positive mention of an employee named Romero. - Two MapQuest customer reviews located for the Exxon service station at the same address: one praises staff professionalism and attentiveness; the other reports a failed inspection over a small windshield-wiper tear. These MapQuest reviews likely refer to the Exxon station and may not reflect 1820 Excellent Auto’s services or reputation. - Summary conclusion: no substantive customer reviews specifically about auto repair work at 1820 Excellent Auto were found; only car-wash praise (Romero) and nearby Exxon reviews of uncertain attribution.
5 FINGERBOARD GAS
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10305
Customers consistently praise 5 FINGERBOARD GAS for honesty and fair pricing, efficient and fast repairs, clear explanations from staff, and high-quality workmanship. These points summarize the available latest customer feedback; no earlier summary was provided for comparison.
717 AUTO SERVICE
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10304
Mixed customer feedback. Key points from the latest and prior reviews consolidated: - Positive reports: Several customers specifically praise mechanic George for honesty and dependable repairs. - Recurring negatives: - Customer service concerns: multiple customers describe staff as rude, dismissive, or unhelpful; some report unprofessional behavior after service. - Oil-change issues: several customers say vehicles developed smoke, leaks, or an unpleasant odor after an oil change. - Pricing complaints: multiple customers allege overcharging — one cited paying about $265 for a part they later found elsewhere for roughly $35 (with a lifetime warranty). - Overall tone: reviews are mixed but show a pattern of repeated customer-service and pricing complaints alongside isolated positive experiences with a particular mechanic. Specializes in Maintenance.
A&N AUTO REPAIR CORP
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10310
A1 AMOCO AUTO CENTER
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10314
Overall sentiment: Mixed Strengths (frequent customer comments) - Commendations for helpful and competent service from staff members, with specific positive mentions of an employee named Jimmy and the mechanics. Weaknesses (if any) - Reports of unexpected or poorly explained charges on bills. - Multiple customers have raised concerns about surcharges being added to debit card transactions. Specializes in Maintenance, Tires.
AAMCO TRANSMISSIONS
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10304
AAMCO Transmissions (635 Richmond Road, Staten Island) is consistently praised by customers for honesty, clear communication, technical expertise and thorough, transparent repairs. Reviewers frequently name staff members Roger, Joe, and Jerry for knowledgeable, helpful service. Customers also highlight fair/reasonable pricing and strong/excellent customer service. Prior aggregated customer metrics indicated very high satisfaction (about 93 customer reviews with an average near 4.9/5 and roughly 93% five-star ratings), which aligns with the latest feedback. Specializes in Diagnostic, Brakes and Traction Control, Transmission and Drivetrain, Maintenance, Steering and Suspension. ASE Certified, AAA Approved Auto Repair Facility
ACE DISCOUNT TIRES
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10303
Mostly positive customer feedback with these recurring themes: - Customers praise prompt service, fair pricing, and friendly, honest staff. - Reviews emphasize quick turnaround and reliable workmanship. - One isolated negative review alleges rudeness and overpriced services; this appears to be an outlier rather than a common pattern. - No organizational ratings included — all comments reflect individual customer experiences. Specializes in Tires.
ALBOS AUTO REPAIR
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10304
Overall sentiment: Positive Strengths (frequent customer comments) - The mechanic is friendly, knowledgeable, and trustworthy. - The service is affordable and prices are fair. - Repairs are done quickly and efficiently. - The shop provides honest assessments of necessary repairs. Weaknesses (if any) - No weaknesses were frequently mentioned in the available reviews.
ALBS AUTO REPAIR
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10314
Overall sentiment: Positive Strengths (frequent customer comments) - Praised for honesty and trustworthiness in diagnosing issues. - Consistently fair and reasonable pricing. - High-quality and reliable repair work. - Quick and efficient service with fast turnaround times. - Professional and clear communication with customers. - Family-oriented and welcoming customer experience leading to long-term loyalty. Weaknesses (if any) - No significant negative trends or recurring issues were found in customer reviews. Specializes in Tires.
ALL TIRE & SERVICE
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10306
Customers frequently commend All Tire & Service for their professionalism, efficient service, and courteous staff. Specializes in Tires.
AMBOY DIAGNOSTIC
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10312
Overall sentiment: Mixed Strengths (frequent customer comments) - Expertise in diagnosing and fixing issues correctly. - Technicians are often described as knowledgeable and getting to the point. - Good customer service. Weaknesses (if any) - Some customers have reported feeling that the business is unfriendly. - There have been allegations of being overcharged or being charged for a premium service that was not provided. Specializes in Diagnostic.
AMG AUTO REPAIR CORP
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10303
Overall sentiment: Mixed Strengths (frequent customer comments) - Professional and punctual service Weaknesses (if any) - One customer reported a 'Bad service' experience.
ANDY&FRANK AUTO
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10310
ANDYS AUTO SALES
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10310
ANGELO LEOTTA
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10309
ANNADALE SERVICE
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10312
Overall sentiment: Positive Strengths (frequent customer comments) - Fast, friendly, and honest service. - Prompt and courteous staff. - Knowledgeable with upfront and fair pricing. - Long-time owner provides personal attention. Weaknesses (if any) - None apparent in the provided reviews.
ANR II AUTOMOTIVE
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10312
ANTHONYS COMPLETE
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10307
ARDEN SHELL CORP
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10312
Overall sentiment: Not Available Strengths (frequent customer comments) - Weaknesses (if any) - .
AUTO
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10303
AUTO LANKA INC
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10303
AUTO MASTERS OF
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10303
AUTO WORKS GROUP INC
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10302
AUTOMASTER REPAIR
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10310
Common Repairs & Costs in Staten Island
Understand typical pricing for popular auto services in the Staten Island area before you visit a mechanic.
Auto Repair in Staten Island — Common Questions
How do I find a good mechanic in Staten Island?+
Start by browsing our directory of verified Staten Island auto repair shops above. Look for shops with strong reviews, relevant specialties for your vehicle, and transparent pricing. You can also upload your mechanic's quote to our free AI tool to check if you're being charged fairly.
How much does auto repair cost in Staten Island?+
Repair costs in Staten Island, New York vary based on the service type, vehicle make, and shop. Common services like oil changes typically run $30–$80, while brake pads range from $150–$400 per axle. For an accurate comparison, upload your quote and our AI will compare prices against local benchmarks.
What should I look for in a Staten Island auto repair shop?+
Look for ASE-certified mechanics, transparent written estimates, positive reviews, and shops that specialize in your vehicle type. Our directory shows each shop's specialties and recommendations. Check our Repair FAQs to learn typical costs and what questions to ask your mechanic.
Already have a repair quote?
Upload your mechanic's bill and our AI will tell you if the prices are fair.
Check Your Quote →