Auto Repair Directory

Find A Trusted Auto Repair Shop in Staten Island

Browse 190 verified auto repair shops in Staten Island, New York.

1820 EXCELLENT AUTO

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10306

- Limited customer reviews found for 1820 Excellent Auto (1820 Richmond Rd, Staten Island, NY); none clearly describe repair services. - Available customer feedback pertains mainly to car wash services and includes a positive mention of an employee named Romero. - Two MapQuest customer reviews located for the Exxon service station at the same address: one praises staff professionalism and attentiveness; the other reports a failed inspection over a small windshield-wiper tear. These MapQuest reviews likely refer to the Exxon station and may not reflect 1820 Excellent Auto’s services or reputation. - Summary conclusion: no substantive customer reviews specifically about auto repair work at 1820 Excellent Auto were found; only car-wash praise (Romero) and nearby Exxon reviews of uncertain attribution.

5 FINGERBOARD GAS

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10305

Customers consistently praise 5 FINGERBOARD GAS for honesty and fair pricing, efficient and fast repairs, clear explanations from staff, and high-quality workmanship. These points summarize the available latest customer feedback; no earlier summary was provided for comparison.

717 AUTO SERVICE

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10304

Mixed customer feedback. Key points from the latest and prior reviews consolidated: - Positive reports: Several customers specifically praise mechanic George for honesty and dependable repairs. - Recurring negatives: - Customer service concerns: multiple customers describe staff as rude, dismissive, or unhelpful; some report unprofessional behavior after service. - Oil-change issues: several customers say vehicles developed smoke, leaks, or an unpleasant odor after an oil change. - Pricing complaints: multiple customers allege overcharging — one cited paying about $265 for a part they later found elsewhere for roughly $35 (with a lifetime warranty). - Overall tone: reviews are mixed but show a pattern of repeated customer-service and pricing complaints alongside isolated positive experiences with a particular mechanic. Specializes in Maintenance.

Maintenance

A&N AUTO REPAIR CORP

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10310

A1 AMOCO AUTO CENTER

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10314

Mixed customer feedback. Positive reports praise staff and service quality—several customers specifically name Jimmy and the shop mechanics for helpful, competent service. Multiple customers also report billing problems: unexpected or unexplained charges and added debit‑card surcharges are recurring complaints. Overall takeaway: customers’ experiences are split between good service from staff/technicians and frustrations over billing transparency and extra fees. Specializes in Maintenance, Tires.

MaintenanceTires

AAMCO TRANSMISSIONS

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10304

AAMCO Transmissions (635 Richmond Road, Staten Island) is consistently praised by customers for honesty, clear communication, technical expertise and thorough, transparent repairs. Reviewers frequently name staff members Roger, Joe, and Jerry for knowledgeable, helpful service. Customers also highlight fair/reasonable pricing and strong/excellent customer service. Prior aggregated customer metrics indicated very high satisfaction (about 93 customer reviews with an average near 4.9/5 and roughly 93% five-star ratings), which aligns with the latest feedback. Specializes in Diagnostic, Brakes and Traction Control, Transmission and Drivetrain, Maintenance, Steering and Suspension. ASE Certified, AAA Approved Auto Repair Facility

DiagnosticBrakes and Traction Control

ACE DISCOUNT TIRES

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10303

Mostly positive customer feedback with these recurring themes: - Customers praise prompt service, fair pricing, and friendly, honest staff. - Reviews emphasize quick turnaround and reliable workmanship. - One isolated negative review alleges rudeness and overpriced services; this appears to be an outlier rather than a common pattern. - No organizational ratings included — all comments reflect individual customer experiences. Specializes in Tires.

Tires

ALBOS AUTO REPAIR

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10304

Albos Auto Repair (450C Front Street, Staten Island, NY) — Customer-sourced summary: 4.9/5 from 35 reviews. Reviewers consistently praise the shop’s professionalism, clear communication about repairs and costs, reasonable pricing, efficient/fast turnaround, and attentive, friendly service.

ALBS AUTO REPAIR

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10314

Sentiment is overwhelmingly positive. Customers consistently praise ALBS Auto Repair for honesty and trustworthiness, noting accurate diagnoses, no upselling, and clear communication. Reviews highlight professionalism, fair and reasonable pricing, reliable repairs, quick turnaround times, and efficient service. Many reviewers describe a family-oriented, welcoming customer experience and report long-term loyalty and repeat business; numerous customers recommend the shop to others. No significant negative trends or gaps were reported in the available summaries. Specializes in Tires.

Tires

ALL TIRE & SERVICE

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10306

Customers frequently commend All Tire & Service for their professionalism, efficient service, and courteous staff. Specializes in Tires.

Tires

ALL TIRE & SERVICE

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10310

Overall sentiment: strongly positive. - Staff: frequently described as professional, friendly, courteous, honest, and knowledgeable/expert. - Service: reported as timely and efficient. - Vehicle coverage: customers note service is appropriate for both personal and commercial vehicles. - Customer action: reviewers often recommend the business. Specializes in Tires.

Tires

ALL TIRE & SERVICE

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10312

Mixed customer sentiment. Key positives: - Multiple customers report quick, friendly, professional service for routine work (fast oil changes, inspections) and timely tire repairs. - Staff mentioned by name as helpful and courteous (Allison, Joe). - Several reviews note no high-pressure sales tactics. Key negatives: - Recurring concerns about pricing and perceived unnecessary or questionable repairs. - Specific complaints include estimates/charges in the ~$500–$600 range and a claim of a serpentine belt replacement at ~30,000 miles that customers felt was premature. Overall: reliable, efficient service for routine maintenance and tire work per many customers, but potential issues with cost transparency and repair necessity flagged by others. Specializes in Tires, Brakes and Traction Control, Diagnostic, Maintenance, Engine, Cooling, Exhaust, Transmission and Drivetrain.

TiresBrakes and Traction Control

ALL TIRE & SERVICE

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10309

Overall customer sentiment: positive. Key points from reviews: - Staff praised for thorough, honest, and prompt service. - Multiple customers single out Kevin for consistently reliable help. - Perceived fair and reasonable pricing. - Customers report quick assistance in urgent or roadside situations. - Long-term consistency noted — repeat customers trust the shop over time. - Strong local/community integration; patrons commonly say they’ll return or recommend the shop. ASE certified technicians, AAA Approved, NJ State inspection station

ALL TIRE CO & AUTO

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10304

Predominantly positive customer sentiment: many reviewers praise All Tire Co & Auto for professional, honest service and quality workmanship. Positive comments commonly note dependable repairs and trustworthiness. However, a minority of reviews raise concerns about customer-service interactions — primarily inconsistent communication, occasional perceived rudeness or unhelpful staff, and frustrations around scheduling or wait times. Overall the technical work and integrity of the shop are viewed favorably, with customer-service variability the main recurring negative theme. Specializes in Tires.

Tires

AMBOY DIAGNOSTIC

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10312

Overall sentiment: Mostly positive. Strengths (frequent customer comments) - Honesty and trust in owner Pat — customers repeatedly cite fair, straightforward dealings and trustworthiness. - Reasonable, transparent pricing — many note costs are fair compared with alternatives. - Promptness and reliability — work is generally completed on time; customers report dependable repairs. - Competence — technicians are often described as knowledgeable and capable. Weaknesses (recurring customer concerns) - Communication and customer service — several customers report poor updates, delays in callbacks, or brusque front-desk interactions. - Occasional repair-quality issues — some customers experienced problems after service or needed follow-up repairs. - Inconsistent experience — while many praise the shop, a subset report service lapses that reduce overall reliability. Net takeaway: Customers generally recommend Amboy Diagnostic for honest, reasonably priced, and reliable repairs—especially valuing owner Pat’s integrity—while advising prospective customers to confirm communication expectations and be aware that a minority report follow-up or quality issues. Specializes in Diagnostic.

Diagnostic

AMG AUTO REPAIR CORP

NINO AUTO REPAIR INC

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10306

NISSAN OF STATEN

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10305

TCSS AUTO

ZALOOMIE CAR CARE

STATEN ISLAND, NY 10314

Already have a repair quote?

Upload your mechanic's bill and our AI will tell you if the prices are fair.

Check Your Quote →