Service Buddy
Auto Repair Profile

STATE TO STATE AUTOMOTIVE

📍1332 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216

The Expert Verdict

State to State Automotive, formerly known as A9's Automotive, is a permanently closed auto repair shop previously located at 1332 Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn, New York. The business specialized in collision repairs and towing, often taking in vehicles that had been involved in recent accidents.

Despite offering automotive bodywork, the shop gained a notorious reputation across the Brooklyn community. Throughout 2025 and 2026, State to State Automotive became the subject of extensive investigations by local news outlets, the New York Department of Motor Vehicles, and the NYPD. Customers frequently reported that the business held their vehicles hostage for months or even over a year, demanding exorbitant storage fees and refusing to release cars despite receiving full insurance payouts. Furthermore, the shop reportedly racked up thousands of dollars in illegal parking tickets on customer vehicles by abandoning them on local streets.

Official records revealed that the shop operated with an expired license and systematically failed to provide proper work orders to patrons. Following a December 2025 NYPD raid that resulted in the removal of over 20 illegally held vehicles from the premises and surrounding streets, the facility ceased legitimate operations. It maintains an 'F' rating with the Better Business Bureau.

Customer Review Summary

📊Overall sentiment: Negative

Strategic Strengths

  • None found in recent reputable sources.

Operational Considerations

  • Holding vehicles for months or over a year.
  • Demanding payment for repairs that were allegedly already paid for by insurance.
  • Racking up parking tickets on customer vehicles.
  • Operating without a proper license.
  • Failure to provide proper paperwork for vehicles.
  • Numerous Better Business Bureau complaints.

Other Auto Repair Shops in Brooklyn

View all shops in Brooklyn

Ready for an uncompromising service?

Compare your mechanic's estimate to fair market prices with our free AI-powered audit.