ALL PRO TIRE & AUTO
📍92 Carleton Ave, Islip, NY 11722
The Expert Verdict
All Pro Tire & Auto, located at 92 Carleton Ave in Islip, NY, is recognized as a reputable auto repair shop specializing in a comprehensive range of tire services and general auto maintenance. The shop is known for its commitment to customer satisfaction, providing honest diagnostics, fair pricing, and efficient service. Many long-standing customers highlight the trustworthy nature of the staff, particularly mentioning individuals like Augie and Julie, who are often praised for their excellent customer care and responsiveness. While specializing in tire installations, repairs, replacements, rotations, and wheel balancing and alignment, All Pro Tire & Auto also extends its expertise to other essential automotive services.
✓ Details last verified October 2026
Customer Review Summary
Overall sentiment for All Pro Tire & Auto is predominantly positive, reflected in a 'Great' satisfaction score of 77 out of 100 from AutoRepairScore, placing it in the top 42% of ranked shops in New York. Customers frequently commend the shop for its reliable service and professionalism.
**Strengths:**
* Honest and trustworthy service.
* Fair and reasonable pricing.
* Quick and efficient service.
* Excellent customer service, with staff members like Augie and Julie receiving specific praise.
* Knowledgeable technicians.
**Weaknesses:**
* A few isolated complaints mention instances of perceived overpricing or rude staff.
* One customer reported a negative experience with a $500 charge for what they considered bad service.
Read Reviews & Local Discussions
✓ Public reviews analyzed October 2026
Technical Competencies
Specialization MatrixTire & Wheel
View Tire & Wheel Benchmarks →Oil Change
View Oil Change Benchmarks →Brake Service
View Brake Service Benchmarks →Engine Repair
View Engine Repair Benchmarks →Suspension & Steering
View Suspension & Steering Benchmarks →Diagnostic & Inspection
View Diagnostic & Inspection Benchmarks →DIY Repair Tutorials
Popular repair videos for services offered at All Pro Tire & Auto. Watch before your visit or tackle it yourself.
🎬 DIY Tutorials
Watch how to do this repair yourself
Other Auto Repair Shops in Islip
View all shops in Islip →Ready for an uncompromising service?
Compare your mechanic's estimate to fair market prices with our free AI-powered audit.