SILVER LAKE AUTO & TIRE CENTERS
📍S73W16610 W Janesville Rd, Muskego, WI

The Expert Verdict
“Silver Lake Auto & Tire Centers in Muskego, WI, is a trusted, family-owned automotive repair shop with a legacy spanning over 50 years, founded in 1973 by Walter “Wally” Garlock and now operated by his sons, Dan and Darren Garlock. This AAA-approved and NAPA AutoCare Center is a leading dealership alternative in Waukesha County, committed to providing exceptional service and quality repairs. They offer a comprehensive range of services for all vehicle types, including domestic, European, fleet, electric, hybrid, and diesel models, handling everything from routine maintenance to major repairs.
Distinguishing themselves through technical excellence and genuine care, Silver Lake Auto & Tire Centers boasts a team of highly competent and ASE-Certified technicians who utilize industry-leading tools and diagnostic equipment. They are recognized for their transparent inspections, fair pricing, and timely repairs. Beyond the bay, the shop prioritizes customer convenience with services like complimentary local shuttle service, free loaner cars (including hybrid options), and a commitment to clear communication throughout the repair process, ensuring customers are informed and confident.
Dedicated to community and customer satisfaction, Silver Lake Auto & Tire Centers stands by its work with a 3-year/36,000-mile warranty through NAPA AutoCare for most services. They aim to make auto repair a breeze, offering convenient online scheduling and walk-in appointments, along with thoughtful touches like complimentary car washes and fresh-baked cookies.”
✓ Details last verified July 2026
Customer Review Summary
Strategic Strengths
- ✓Friendly and communicative staff
- ✓Fast, efficient, and timely service
- ✓Detailed and thorough inspections
- ✓Exceptional customer service with a personal touch
- ✓Convenient services like free loaner cars and shuttle service
- ✓Transparent communication and fair pricing
Operational Considerations
- ℹPerceived higher pricing than some alternatives
- ℹOccasional comments about oil changes and tire rotations being more expensive, comparable to dealerships
Technical Competencies
Specialization MatrixTires
Maintenance
Brakes and Traction Control
Diagnostic
Services Offered
Standard Service CatalogOil Change
View Repair Costs & Guide →🛑Brake Service
View Repair Costs & Guide →🛞Tire & Wheel
View Repair Costs & Guide →⚡Battery & Electrical
View Repair Costs & Guide →⚙️Transmission
View Repair Costs & Guide →🔧Engine Repair
View Repair Costs & Guide →🏎️Suspension & Steering
View Repair Costs & Guide →❄️AC & Heating
View Repair Costs & Guide →🔍Diagnostic & Inspection
View Repair Costs & Guide →💨Exhaust & Emissions
View Repair Costs & Guide →🌡️Cooling System
View Repair Costs & Guide →🧹Filters & Maintenance
View Repair Costs & Guide →〰️Fluids & Belts
View Repair Costs & Guide →Drivetrain (CV
Axles
Differential)
State Inspection
View Repair Costs & Guide →DIY Repair Tutorials
Popular repair videos for services offered at Silver Lake Auto & Tire Centers. Watch before your visit or tackle it yourself.
🎬 DIY Tutorials
Watch how to do this repair yourself
Ready for an uncompromising service?
Compare your mechanic's estimate to fair market prices with our free AI-powered audit.