About This Shop
a highly rated full-service tire and auto repair shop in STATEN ISLAND, NY
💬Customer Review Summary
Predominantly positive customer sentiment: many reviewers praise All Tire Co & Auto for professional, honest service and quality workmanship. Positive comments commonly note dependable repairs and trustworthiness. However, a minority of reviews raise concerns about customer-service interactions — primarily inconsistent communication, occasional perceived rudeness or unhelpful staff, and frustrations around scheduling or wait times. Overall the technical work and integrity of the shop are viewed favorably, with customer-service variability the main recurring negative theme.
Individual Reviews
Dissatisfied with counter staff; described them as very rude and advised others not to waste their time due to inefficient service. — Dec 15, 2025 — mapquest.com — Source
Commended the shop for honesty; informed that new shocks were not necessary at the time. — Dec 15, 2025 — carfax.com — Source
After a highway blowout, shop provided a good price for new tires, identified failing tie rods (potentially preventing an accident); praised fair pricing, clean waiting room, and excellent service. — Dec 15, 2025 — carfax.com — Source
Technician inspected a screw in rear tire, determined the tire was not punctured, removed the screw, and did not charge for the service. — Dec 15, 2025 — carfax.com — Source
Praised the professionalism of the front desk; Vinny assisted multiple times; appreciated prompt service for an oil change and tire issue; repair done quickly and at no charge since the tires were purchased from them. — Dec 15, 2025 — carfax.com — Source
Highlighted the honesty of the staff; informed that new shocks were not necessary at the time. — Dec 15, 2025 — carfax.com — Source
190 Rhine Ave, Staten Island, NY 10304, STATEN ISLAND, NY 10304
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10304
Owner
SI ALL TIRE &
State Inspection
This auto shop offers NY state inspection. Facility #7115375
Specialties
Amenities & Features
Got a repair quote?
Compare your mechanic's estimate to fair market prices with our free AI-powered audit.
Check Your Quote