ALL TIRE & SERVICE
Auto Repair in STATEN ISLAND, NY 10312
💬Customer Review Summary
Mixed customer sentiment. Key positives:
Multiple customers report quick, friendly, professional service for routine work (fast oil changes, inspections) and timely tire repairs.
Staff mentioned by name as helpful and courteous (Allison, Joe).
Several reviews note no high-pressure sales tactics.
Key negatives:
Recurring concerns about pricing and perceived unnecessary or questionable repairs.
Specific complaints include estimates/charges in the ~$500–$600 range and a claim of a serpentine belt replacement at ~30,000 miles that customers felt was premature.
Overall: reliable, efficient service for routine maintenance and tire work per many customers, but potential issues with cost transparency and repair necessity flagged by others.
Individual Reviews
Customer praised quick service—oil changes and inspections completed in 30-40 minutes—and appreciated friendly staff. — Dec 15, 2025 — MapQuest — Source
Reviewer dissatisfied after being charged over $500 for routine service on a 2022 Honda Civic; serpentine belt replacement was deemed unnecessary at 30,000 miles. — Dec 15, 2025 — MapQuest — Source
Customer reported being informed of multiple issues during an inspection with a $600 repair estimate and warned against driving; a second opinion found no problems, leading to questions about the initial assessment. — Dec 15, 2025 — MapQuest — Source
Customer commended staff (Allison and Joe) for friendliness and helpfulness addressing an under-car noise. — Dec 15, 2025 — MapQuest — Source
Reviewer highlighted professionalism and courtesy of staff, absence of hard-sell tactics, and recommended the shop. — Dec 15, 2025 — Chamber of Commerce — Source
Customer appreciated quick service and excellent customer service when having a tire repaired; work completed on time as promised. — Dec 15, 2025 — Chamber of Commerce — Source
4467 Amboy Road, Staten Island, NY 10312, STATEN ISLAND, NY 10312
STATEN ISLAND, NY 10312
Hours
Open 7 days per week; specific weekday hours not provided. Saturday: 7:30 AM - 4:00 PM.
Owner
SI ALL TIRE &
State Inspection
This auto shop offers NY state inspection. Facility #7118770
Specialties
Amenities & Features
Got a repair quote?
Compare your mechanic's estimate to fair market prices with our free AI-powered audit.
Check Your Quote