A1 AUTO REPAIR INC
📍1205 CONEY ISL S A&B, BROOKLYN, NY 11230
Customer Review Summary
Mixed customer sentiment: many reviewers praise A1 AUTO REPAIR INC for quality workmanship, fair/priced estimates, responsive service, and professional staff; however, a notable minority report ineffective repairs that required follow-ups and unexpected or upcharged costs. Key positives — service quality, pricing, responsiveness, professionalism. Key negatives — repairs that didn’t fully resolve issues, surprise or additional charges, and resulting return visits.
Technical Competencies
Specialization MatrixStarting and Charging
Windows and Glass
Maintenance
Services Offered
Standard Service CatalogBrake service
oil changes
and other repairs for multiple makes and models
Individual Reviews
Praise for trustworthiness, reasonable prices, top-notch customer service, quality work, responsiveness, flexible hours, and personable staff. — Dec 15, 2025 — carfax.com — Source
Appreciated quick and polite service replacing three lightbulbs in the right brake light; total price $40 and noted as reasonable. — Dec 15, 2025 — carfax.com — Source
Dissatisfied: shop did not know how to fix the car, was quick to take money, did not inform customer of the problem; customer went to a dealership instead. — Dec 15, 2025 — carfax.com — Source
Praised professionalism; repairs done correctly the first time without repeat visits; reasonable pricing and top-quality service. — Dec 15, 2025 — carfax.com — Source
Expressed distrust after being upcharged twice; after initial quote had to pay for parts that 'mysteriously' broke or malfunctioned while the car was in the shop's possession. — Dec 15, 2025 — mapquest.com — Source
Positive experience with quick turnaround; shop did a good job restoring car to like-new; would recommend for body work. — Dec 15, 2025 — mapquest.com — Source
Real Repair Quotes
Real quotes submitted by customers of A1 AUTO REPAIR INC. Each includes a fairness verdict and price comparison.
Other Auto Repair Shops in BROOKLYN
View all shops in BROOKLYN →State to State Automotive
Brooklyn, NY
Overall sentiment: Negative Strengths (frequent customer comments) - None found in recent reputable sources. Weaknesses (if any) - Holding vehicles for months or over a year. - Demanding payment for repairs that were allegedly already paid for by insurance. - Racking up parking tickets on customer vehicles. - Operating without a proper license. - Failure to provide proper paperwork for vehicles. - Numerous Better Business Bureau complaints.
HOLLYLAND AUTO
BROOKLYN, NY 11215
ONE STOP 86 ST INC
BROOKLYN, NY 11228
Ready for an uncompromising service?
Compare your mechanic's estimate to fair market prices with our free AI-powered audit.